Residency call schedule software comparison (November 2026): how to make a fair call schedule
Residency call schedule software compared by who builds the schedule, plus a step-by-step way to build a fair call schedule residents can check for themselves.
Residency scheduling software compared, November 2026
This table describes each option by how it works, not by price. Most of these tools do not publish a price, so ask each vendor directly.
Who builds the call schedule in each option
From each vendor’s own site, checked November 11, 2026.
| Option | Approach | Who builds the call schedule | What it does well | Where programs struggle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Spreadsheet (Excel, Google Sheets) | Grid you fill in | You | Free, flexible, everyone knows it | Rules interact; formulas flag a broken rule only after you break it |
| Amion | Schedule publishing and on-call lookup | You, with your own rules and templates, and automatic fill around requests | Widely used, easy for staff to see who is on call | You build and maintain the rules, templates and layouts yourself |
| QGenda | Workforce management platform for health systems | Its automated, rules-based engine, from rules you set | Broad scope across departments, specialties and roles | Built for whole health systems; request a demo and quote on your own rules |
| Lightning Bolt | Rules based auto-scheduling | You set rules, the tool drafts | Strong at rule driven physician schedules | Sold through PerfectServe with a custom deployment and custom pricing |
| Intrigma | Scheduling software with auto-scheduling | You set rules, the tool drafts | Physician, nurse and residency schedules; a free scheduler | Its residency page covers rotations and goals such as “4 ICU blocks” but does not describe call scheduling |
| Chiefly | Residency scheduling software and a service for GME programs | Chiefly’s team loads the rules, the software generates the schedule, chiefs re-run it | Built for residency programs, with rule-checked swaps | Chiefs can re-run schedules or ask their dedicated advisor when things change |
| Scheduling Wizard | Managed scheduling service | Their team | You hand off the build | Revisions go back to their team; its site does not say how mid-year swaps are handled |
| Thrawn | Managed service using optimization | Their team | Optimized drafts built for you | Changes go back to Thrawn to re-optimize; you review and approve |
| jacks | Set up together, then jacks builds and runs the year | jacks, from your rules | Every draft passes every rule; fair against each person’s target; call-outs, swaps and calendars handled all year | Early access; programs request it at jacks.med/#access |
A simplification for comparison. Products change; ask each vendor to show you every step with your own rules. MedHub and New Innovations are residency management systems that programs keep alongside any of these tools.
For a deeper look at single tools, see Amion alternatives, QGenda alternatives and best residency scheduling software.
How to make a fair call schedule for residents
Call schedules usually land on a chief resident on top of a full clinical load. The first draft is not the hard part. The hard part is that every rule touches every other rule: one vacation request moves a weekend, which breaks someone’s rest, which puts a PGY-1 on a night with no senior backup. Then a swap request arrives and you start over. These six steps hold up across a whole year, by hand or with software.
1. Write the hard rules down first
A hard rule is one the schedule can never break without someone signing off. Put them on one page before you place a single name. Write each one as a sentence a co-chief could check by looking at the schedule. “No AM shift the morning after a PM shift” can be checked. “Be reasonable about rest” cannot.
A rule you can check by looking
“No AM shift the morning after a PM shift.” Same weekend, two drafts.
Draft A No rest after PM
Draft B Every rule checked
Most programs have two layers. The ACGME floor is below. On top of it sit your program’s rules, which cause most of the conflicts:
- Who can take which shift. Interns on primary call only with a senior on backup; backup limited to PGY-3 and up; a site that needs a PGY-2 or above.
- Rotation conflicts. Nobody on nights, vacation or certain off-service rotations takes weekend call, and nobody takes the Sunday before starting a nights week.
- Caps. At most three shifts in one weekend, at most two backups in one weekend, a yearly cap on 24-hour doubles.
2. Collect time off before you start
Every request you take after the draft is a rebuild. Open one window for vacation, conferences, boards and life events, close it, then build. Decide up front what happens to late requests: they go on a waitlist, or they need a swap partner.
3. Decide what fair means, in numbers
Pick the counts you will track and publish them. More on this below.
4. Build the year, not the month
Fairness is a yearly count, but most schedules are built a month at a time. Each month looks even on its own and the year still drifts: the same people catch the long weekends, or one class quietly carries more backup. Build the whole year as one draft, publish it in blocks, and look at year-to-date counts before you fix next month. Our block schedule templates help with the rotation side.
5. Check every rule after every change
Rules rarely break in the first draft. They break in March, on the fourth swap. A Friday PM swap can land someone on a Saturday AM with no rest. After any edit, recheck the whole schedule, not just the two cells that moved. Our free duty-hours checker does it for one resident’s four weeks.
6. Plan for call-outs before they happen
Someone will get sick on a holiday weekend. Decide now who covers: a jeopardy or backup pool, an order of who gets asked, and whether coverage counts toward their totals. Then a call-out is a two-minute decision, not a group text at 5 a.m.
The ACGME rules every call schedule must pass
These come from the ACGME Common Program Requirements. Your specialty’s Review Committee can tighten them, so check your own program requirements too. For the detail, see ACGME duty hours and the call schedule.
| Rule | Limit | How it is measured |
|---|---|---|
| Weekly clinical and educational work | 80 hours | Averaged over four weeks, counting in-house work, clinical work from home and moonlighting |
| Days free | One day in seven | Averaged over four weeks; at-home call cannot be scheduled on those days |
| In-house call frequency | No more often than every third night | Averaged over four weeks |
| Continuous clinical work | 24 hours | Plus up to four hours for handoffs and education |
| Rest between shifts | Eight hours off should separate scheduled work | Between scheduled shifts |
| Rest after 24-hour call | At least 14 hours off | After 24 hours of in-house call |
What fair means, in numbers
“Fair” causes more arguments than any rule, because everyone keeps a different count. Track these and show them to everyone:
- Calls per person against a target. PGY-1s and PGY-4s rarely carry the same load, so equal for everyone is the wrong goal. The target can be an even split, a share by FTE or class, or a number the program sets.
- Weekends and holidays, counted separately. A resident with an average total who works Thanksgiving and Christmas is not being treated fairly.
- Golden weekends (fully off) and 24-hour doubles per person.
A worked example: one PGY-3 class with a target of 12 weekends for the year. Six residents land at 11, 12 or 13. One has 15 and one has 9. The class average looks fine, but the six-weekend gap between those two is the gap residents talk about, and it usually grows from small choices made one month at a time. Comparing each person to their own target, not to the average, is what catches it. Scheduling attendings? See weighting nights, weekends and holidays.
Fair is a count against a target, per class
Example: one PGY-3 class, weekends worked this year, against a target of 12 (dashed line).
Every total is close to average. But one resident worked six more weekends than another, and that’s the gap residents talk about.
What to ask any tool in a comparison
Whatever you are evaluating, hold it to this list:
- Does every draft pass every rule? Not most rules, every one, including your program’s caps and rotation conflicts.
- Is fairness measured per person, against a target? And can residents see their own counts?
- When a seat can’t be filled, does it tell you which rule is in the way? Sometimes a weekend can’t be staffed because too many people are on nights or away. The useful answer is which rule to bend.
- Can you edit by hand and have the whole schedule rechecked?
- Do published weeks stay put when the rest of the year is rebuilt?
- What happens on a call-out? Who gets the shift, does it count, and is the owed call tracked for payback?
- Who sets it up? Your rules shouldn’t be something you configure alone at midnight.
Tempted to ask a chatbot instead? We tested that on a real program’s year.
When a spreadsheet is still enough
A spreadsheet is a fine place to record a schedule. For a small program with few rules and one site, it can also be a fine place to build one. It gets hard when rules interact: formulas flag a problem after you make it but cannot look three moves ahead for an arrangement that breaks nothing. It cannot tell you when the rules are impossible. And balancing a full year of weekends against class targets, then doing it again after every swap, is where most chiefs run out of evenings.
How it starts with jacks
Setup is done together. jacks sits down with your chief resident, coordinator or attending scheduler and turns how your program runs into rules: rest after call, who can work what, coverage per service, caps, time off and fairness targets. jacks builds the schedule, and every draft passes every rule. When a seat can’t be filled, jacks names the rule in the way. You make the final calls: tell jacks a new rule in plain words and it adds it and rebuilds, or move anything by hand and it rechecks the whole schedule.
Then jacks runs the year: swaps, call-outs, time-off requests and calendars. When someone calls out, their service and calls move to whoever is eligible and furthest under their target, owed calls are tracked for payback, and everyone affected gets the change on their phone and calendar. Published weeks stay put when the rest is rebuilt. It covers call, block rotations for a full academic year, daily OR case assignment with resident case-log progress, and preference surveys with calendar sync. jacks is in early access; programs request it at jacks.med/#access.
Questions programs ask
What is the difference between rule-checking software and a tool that builds the schedule?
Rule-checking software flags a broken rule after you place a name. A tool that builds the schedule searches for an arrangement that breaks none of them and tells you which rule is in the way when no arrangement exists.
How can software help with ACGME duty hour compliance?
It can turn the ACGME Common Program Requirements, plus your Review Committee’s additions, into rules every draft must pass, and recheck them after every swap. The program still owns the rules and the final schedule.
What is a managed scheduling service for residencies?
A team, such as Scheduling Wizard or Thrawn, builds your schedules for you from a description of how your program runs. jacks also sets up with you, and then you can change rules and move shifts yourself and the whole schedule is rechecked.
How do we make call and holiday distribution fair?
Set a target per person, an even split, a share by FTE or class, or a number you choose, and count weekends and holidays separately from total calls. Publish the counts so residents can check them.
Why does one sick call break the whole schedule?
Coverage moves a shift, and the moved shift can break rest or caps days away. jacks gives the shift to whoever is eligible and furthest under their target, tracks the owed call and rechecks every rule.
How do programs keep scheduling knowledge when chiefs change?
Write the rules as checkable sentences and keep them in the tool, not in one chief’s head. With jacks, the rules set up together carry into next year’s build.
Is jacks available now?
jacks is in early access. Programs request it at jacks.med/#access.