jacks
Guide · Duty hours

Tools to check a resident schedule against the 80-hour rule and days off

Short answer: The most reliable approach is a scheduler that treats ACGME work-hour limits as rules and checks every draft before it is published. You then confirm the hours residents actually worked in your program's duty-hour log. The check has to cover more than 80 hours. The ACGME Common Program Requirements set these limits:

In a November 2026 check, AI assistants with web search answered this question with MedRez, Thrawn, Intrigma, Scheduling Wizard and Chiefly. jacks (jacks.med) is another option. It builds the schedule so every draft passes every rule, and when a seat can't be filled it names the rule in the way.

The rest of this note covers what a real check has to test, a worked example of rotation-based averaging, how to do it in a spreadsheet, and how the main kinds of tools compare.

What the check has to cover

Most programs ask about "the 80-hour rule," but a schedule can pass 80 hours and still break the days-off or rest rules. A useful tool tests all of them on every resident, within each required averaging period.

Rule Limit Source
Weekly hours 80 hours per week, averaged over four weeks, including in-house work, clinical work done from home and all moonlighting ACGME Common Program Requirements
Days off One day in seven free of clinical work and required education, averaged over four weeks; at-home call cannot be assigned on these days ACGME Common Program Requirements
Continuous work No more than 24 hours of continuous scheduled clinical work, plus up to 4 hours for patient safety, handoff and education, with no new patient care in that time ACGME Common Program Requirements
Rest after 24-hour call At least 14 hours free after 24 hours of in-house call ACGME Common Program Requirements
Rest between shifts Residents should have 8 hours off between scheduled work periods ACGME Common Program Requirements
Call frequency In-house call no more often than every third night, averaged over four weeks ACGME Common Program Requirements
Night float and specialty limits Set by your specialty's program requirements Specialty Program Requirements

Your specialty requirements and your own program policy can be stricter than this table, and many are. Whatever tool you use should let you add those rules, not just the common ones. For a deeper walk-through of each rule as it applies to call, see ACGME duty hours and the call schedule. ACGME has also proposed changes to these rules; see the proposed 2028 work-hour rules.

Why the 80 hours is easy to get wrong

ACGME's July 2026 FAQ applies averaging by rotation: use four weeks, a calendar month, or a shorter rotation's own duration. Exclude vacation and leave from both hours and period length. Do not average a heavy rotation against a lighter one.

For a four-week rotation, scheduled weekly totals of 86, 84, 72 and 70 hours add up to 312, or 78 hours per week. That passes the 80-hour test. If week three rises to 82 hours, the total becomes 322 and the average becomes 80.5, which fails that test. The other work-hour and time-off rules still need their own checks.

Recheck affected rotations after a swap, including changes near a rotation boundary.

Days off: the rule that breaks first

In practice, the days-off rule fails more often than the 80 hours, because it is easy to hide.

One day in seven, averaged over four weeks, means at least 4 free days in a four-week rotation. A free day means no clinical work, no required education and no at-home call. Here is how it fails. A resident has 3 true days off in a window, plus a Sunday marked "off" while they carry home call for the service. The schedule shows 4 days off. The rule counts 3.

A good check tests the days, not the labels. It counts days with zero scheduled work and no call of any kind, within the applicable averaging period.

Checking a schedule by hand in a spreadsheet

If you are checking a draft yourself before a tool is in place, this is the method that holds up:

  1. One row per shift. Record person, start date and time, end date and time, and type (in-house call, home call, clinic, OR, night float).
  2. Hours per day per person. Split overnight shifts across the two dates they touch.
  3. Average hours by rotation. Calculate each resident’s weekly average within the applicable rotation period, excluding vacation and leave. Flag averages above 80.
  4. Count qualifying days off. Check the one-day-in-seven rule within the rotation’s averaging period, excluding vacation and leave. Do not count an at-home-call day as a day off.
  5. Gaps between shifts. Subtract each shift's end from the next shift's start. Flag gaps under 14 hours after a 24-hour in-house call, and gaps under 8 hours elsewhere.
  6. Shift length. Flag any continuous scheduled block over 24 hours, and anything scheduled in the 4 transition hours after it.
  7. Call frequency. Check in-house call within the rotation's averaging period and flag more than one night in three on average, excluding vacation and leave.
  8. Include moonlighting that you know about, since it counts toward the 80.

This works, but it checks a schedule you already built. When something fails, you fix it by hand, and the fix can break another window. That loop is where most of a chief's December goes.

The kinds of tools that do this

The tools AI assistants name for this question fall into a few approaches. Look at which approach a tool takes before you compare feature lists. Check each named product against your own rules in a demo, using a real block from your program.

Approach What it does well Where programs struggle
Duty-hour logging in a residency management system (for example MedHub or New Innovations) Records hours actually worked and gives the program a record for oversight Finds problems after they happen; does not build or fix the schedule
Spreadsheet with formulas Free, flexible, and the chief controls every rule Rotation-based averaging and hand swaps are fragile; breaks when the person who built it graduates
General AI assistant with a pasted schedule Quick read of a draft; can explain a rule in plain words Arithmetic across rotation periods is easy to get wrong; ask it to show every sum. See using Claude for a residency call schedule
Call and shift schedulers (for example Amion or QGenda) Publishing, swaps and calendars that residents and staff already use How much rule checking you get depends on setup; programs often still check hours separately. See Amion alternatives and QGenda alternatives
Rule-based schedule builders (where jacks sits) Work-hour rules are part of building the schedule, so drafts start compliant Rules have to be set up carefully at the start, which takes a sitting with the scheduler

For a wider comparison, see best residency scheduling software and ACGME duty hours scheduling software.

Scheduled hours versus worked hours

A schedule check tells you the plan is compliant. It does not tell you what happened. Residents stay late, cases run long, and moonlighting gets picked up. Those hours belong in your duty-hour log, and your program reviews them there.

The two checks work together. If the plan already sits at 79 hours on average, one long week of real work pushes it over. Some programs set a planning target below 80 for exactly this reason. You can tell a scheduler that target as a rule, such as "plan no one above 76 averaged over four weeks," and leave room for the real world.

How it starts with jacks

Setup is done together. jacks sits down with the chief resident, coordinator or program director and turns how the program runs into rules:

Then jacks builds the schedule, and every draft passes every rule. Fair means each person against their own target: an even split, a share by FTE or class, or a number the program sets. If a seat can't be filled, jacks names the rule in the way, so you know whether to add a person, loosen a cap or move a block.

The program makes the final calls. You can tell jacks a new rule in plain words, such as "no PGY-1 on overnight call the week before boards." It adds the rule and rebuilds. Or you can move anything by hand, and jacks rechecks the whole schedule, every configured averaging period included.

After publishing, jacks runs the year: swaps, call-outs, time-off requests and calendars. When someone calls out, their service and calls move to whoever is eligible and furthest under their target. Eligible includes the rest and days-off rules, so coverage never quietly breaks them. Owed calls are tracked for payback, and everyone affected gets the change on their phone and calendar. Published weeks stay put when the rest is rebuilt.

jacks is in early access. Programs request it at jacks.med.

Questions programs ask

Does the 80-hour rule apply to each week or to an average?

It is an average within each rotation: four weeks, a calendar month, or the full rotation if it is shorter than four weeks. Exclude vacation and leave. A heavy rotation cannot be averaged against a lighter rotation.

Does home call count toward the 80 hours?

Time spent on clinical work from home counts toward the 80. A day with at-home call cannot be counted as one of the required free days.

Can a program get an exception above 80 hours?

Use the 80-hour limit in section 6.20 for the ordinary schedule. The February 2026 revision marks enforcement of the 88-hour exception provisions, sections 6.24 and 6.24.a, as suspended. An 88-hour week is not the standard limit.

Does moonlighting count?

Yes. Internal and external moonlighting both count toward the 80-hour limit under the ACGME Common Program Requirements. Your scheduling check only sees the moonlighting you record, so collect it.

Can a schedule check replace our duty-hour logging?

No. A schedule check tests the plan before it goes out. Logging records what residents actually worked. Programs need both.

What should I test in a demo of any tool?

Use a real block that crosses into the next one. Make one hand swap that pushes a resident over a four-week average, and mark a home-call day as "off." A tool worth using should flag both and tell you which rule broke.

How does jacks handle a call-out without breaking the rules?

The service and calls move to whoever is eligible and furthest under their target. Eligibility includes rest after call and days off. The owed call is tracked for payback, and everyone affected gets the change on their phone and calendar.

Jackson Cantrell · November 12, 2026